Farmers Movement Archive

‘New farm laws are a clear encroachment on State functions’

After pulling out of the National Democratic Alliance (NDA) and the Union government, the Shiromani Akali Dal (SAD) now plans to bring regional parties across the country on one platform to fight against, what it terms, ‘anti-farmer’ laws. Sukhbir Singh Badal, party chief and former Punjab Deputy Chief Minister, says it is sad the BJP was “insensitive” to the huge relevance of the alliance with his party in Punjab against the backdrop of Hindu-Sikh unity. Excerpts : The SAD-BJP alliance in Punjab was seen as symbol of Sikh-Hindu unity. How do you assess the situation after the breaking of the alliance? The values of peace and communal harmony are very dear to us. Mr. Parkash Singh Badal is a symbol of peace and the basic thing he taught us is that Punjab can progress only if there is peace. Badal sahab ’s basic fundamental was that he took every community, every religious organisation together. He took everyone into confidence for everything and that is why everyone trusts him, and that philosophy we will carry on. For us every religion will play equal part in developing Punjab. Punjab is a border State and the Government of India should have been very sensitive. Punjabis and Sikhs are very emotional people. With love, you can take anything from them, but if you do something which hurts them, they get agitated quickly. It is sad that the BJP is insensitive to the huge relevance of our alliance in Punjab for Hindu-Sikh unity. The SAD initially supported agriculture sector ordinances but later decided to alter its stance. The Opposition accuses you of changing your stance only after facing backlash from farmers to save your ‘vote bank’. We never altered our stand from the beginning. When ordinances came to the Cabinet, we had put forward our objections surrounding them. The ordinances were never discussed with us before the Cabinet meeting. In the meeting, we objected. But we were assured that farmers’ reservations would be addressed when these ordinances are converted into Bills for Parliament. We shared the farmers’ concerns and expected that the BJP would accept all of them, but when they did not accept them, we were left with no choice [but to leave the alliance]. In the past few months, I have always been telling farmers that for us [the SAD], any alliance or Ministry is not as important as farmers. Our aim was to gather farmers’ suggestions, and when I held meetings with farm organisations and farm experts, they shared the apprehension that MSP (minimum support price) would be wiped out [by the farm Bills], among other concerns. I conveyed all the objections to the Government of India and the government gave in writing that they will not discontinue MSP. We then took this message to farmers, but the people of the State, including legal experts, suggested that the assurance in writing was not sufficient. So, all this time, we were conveying what the government said to the farmers, and shared the farmers’ view with the government, because we were a part of the NDA. We were assured that they [the Central government] would listen to us. But when they did not listen, we told them we would oppose [them] and walked out of the government. We always remained on one stand. Were you betrayed by the BJP over the farm laws? The BJP should have consulted its allies first. SAD represents farmers. We know more about farmers than the BJP. In an alliance, numbers should not always be used as the method of taking decisions. Instead, a partnership should be considered as the base for decision-making. The SAD had always been advocating more powers to the States. Against this background do you think the agriculture legislation encroaches on the States’ functions? Yes, absolutely. These laws are a clear encroachment on State functions. Agriculture is a State subject but they [the Centre] got the ordinances through the via media of trading, which falls in the Concurrent List. So, the government used the Concurrent List, which is a wrong way to do [this legislation]. We stand for a federal India. These laws are clearly violating the federal principle. After the agriculture Bills were passed in the Rajya Sabha, you said that democratic virtues had been ignored. Can you elaborate? Winning and losing is something different but the system should not be broken. When people in the Rajya Sabha wanted division of votes on the Bills, it should have taken place. Why were the Bills forced? They [the NDA] would still have had the numbers but you cannot just push your way in the manner in which it was done, by bulldozing all norms. The spirit of democracy is consensus, not majoritarian confrontation. People want consensus and peace. No attempt was made in that direction to bring a consensus in Parliament and the Bills were passed in the Rajya Sabha, flouting all democratic traditions. How do you plan to fight against the new agriculture laws? Will you be approaching other political parties, especially the regional parties, to join hands for the farmers’ cause? We will try to get all farmers’ organisations under one platform, emerge as one force, and raise our concerns with the Centre. We will fight these laws at every level, including in the people’s court. Farmers are facing a crisis of life and death, and the nation must come to their rescue. What is happening is that the government has abandoned farmers in favour of corporates. The fire has spread all across the country. We will approach regional parties in the country and try to get all together on a single platform against the Centre’s agriculture legislations and other farmers’ issues. The Assembly elections in Punjab are due in 2022. Do you think the farm legislation will be the key election issue? First let us fight this battle to save our farmers. The ruling Congress government is the most incompetent government that Punjab has ever had. Chief Minister Amarinder Singh is hardly seen in Punjab. He doesn’t meet anybody. Farmers are facing a crisis of life and death, and the nation must come to their rescue

The Hindu

2020-10-01

October 01 2020 00:00 IST