Farmers Movement Archive

You have strangulated entire city, now you want to come inside and protest, SC tells farmers’ body

Tribune News ServiceNew Delhi, October 1The farmers protesting against farm laws received a rap on the knuckles on Friday from the Supreme Court which questioned the rationale behind blocking of roads even after approaching the judiciary and reminded them that citizens have equal rights to move freely without fear.”You have strangulated the entire city, now you want to come inside the city and start protesting again here … The residents around … are they happy with the protest? This business should stop. You are obstructing security and defence personnel. This was in the media. All this should stop … There has to be a balanced approach,” a Bench led by Justice AM Khanwilkar told the counsel for ‘Kisan Mahapanchayat’.“There is no point in protest once you come to the court challenging the laws”, the Bench told the farmers’ body during hearing on its petition seeking directions to the Centre, Delhi Lt. Governor and Delhi Police Commissioner to allow it to stage ‘satyagraha’ at Jantar Mantar in the National Capital.“Are you protesting against the judicial system? Once you have approached the judicial system, have faith in the court. You pursue that matter for urgent hearing instead of protesting again,” the Bench told the counsel for Kisan Mahapanchayat who said the farmers’ body did have faith in the court.After the petitioner’s counsel denied that farmers blocked highways, the Bench asked him to declare it on an affidavit and posted it for hearing on Monday.This is the second consecutive day that the Supreme Court has questioned the continued blockade of roads by protesting farmers. On Thursday, the court had wondered how highways can be blocked perpetually. “The redressal of problems can be through judicial forum, agitation or through parliamentary debates. But how can the highways be blocked, and this is happening perpetually. Where does this end?” another Bench led by Justice SK Kaul had asked. It had said it’s the duty of the executive to implement the law laid down by it.Maintaining that farmers had the right to protest, the top court on Friday emphasised that citizens also enjoyed equal right to move freely and without fear. “Their (citizens’) properties are being damaged. Do you take permission from the residents around whether they are happy with your protest … This coaxing business should stop,” it said.Citing media reports, the Bench pointed out that even security personnel were obstructed, stopped and heckled during the protests.As the petitioner’s counsel said the farmers are holding peaceful protests, the Bench shot back, ”What’s this peaceful protest? You block trains, highways and then you say your protest is peaceful and without causing any harm to the public.”On January 12 this year, the top court stayed the implementation of the three farm laws—the Farmers (Empowerment & Protection) Agreement of Price Assurance & Farm Services Act 2020, Farmers Produce Trade & Commerce (Promotion & Facilitation) Act & Amendment to Essential Commodities Act.It had constituted a four-member panel comprising Pramod Kumar Joshi (Director South Asia international Food Policy), Shetkari Sanghatana President Anil Ghanwat and agriculture-economist and former Chairman of the Commission for Agricultural Costs and Prices (CACP) Ashok Gulati to hear the various stakeholders’ views on and report back to it. The fourth member of the panel Bhartiya Kisan Union President Bhupinder Singh Mann had recused himself. The panel submitted its report to the court in March.

The Tribune

2021-10-02